Mix It Up & Make It Nice

Amateur baker with a passion for eating!

The Great Treacle Tart Recipe Dispute

So last week I decided to make treacle tart. I’d seen the great Mary Berry do it on the Great British Bake Off Masterclass, and I was (naรฏvely) ready for the challenge.

The reason I wanted to make treacle tart in the first place was that it had been the dessert at my grad ball this summer, and my boyfriend had eaten just about everyone else’s portions (because they were too full to finish!) and absolutely loved it. And seeing as he was coming over to mine for Sunday dinner, I thought I’d wow him with my own wonderful treacle tart.

Unfortunately, it didn’t go as I’d envisaged…

Once I’d decided to make it, I was set on Mary Berry’s recipe. Obviously. The woman is the Queen of Baking. Her and Hollywood are the Dream Team ๐Ÿ˜‰ Plus, I’d seen it being made, I knew it worked.

But then my mum cracked out all of her recipe books and started searching for different recipes. The problem was that they all seemed to have such different quantities of the same ingredients and I was overwhelmed. Mum recommended I use a recipe in one of her cookbooks, but use Mary Berry’s tips and tricks. So I did…

Mixing it up and making it nice ;)

Mixing it up and making it nice

It all began quite well… I started by mixing up some butter and plain flour in the mixer, until it reached a “fine bread crumb” consistency.

...until it looks like fine breadcrumbs!

Those are some “fine breadcrumbs”!

Then I added 3 tablespoons of cold water and carried on mixing until I had a hard dough. So far so good.



I rolled out the dough into a very wonky “circle” until it was thin enough & then I somehow got it into my tin without anything breaking or anyone crying ๐Ÿ˜‰ God knows how! I had quite a bit of dough left over, so we ended up using that for a lovely chicken pie… so at least the dough was good, I guess!

Baking my rather empty looking pie

Baking my rather empty looking pie…

Next, it was on to the filling. I whacked some white bread in the mixer to make breadcrumbs and then mixed this up with some warm, runny golden syrup and the juice of one lemon. It was when I started to spread this weird mixture onto my pastry (which isn’t cooked in advance by the way), that I began to feel that something wasn’t quite right.

Firstly, the filling was super thin and looked a bit ridiculous in my fairly deep pastry tin (which the recipe specifically called f0r…). Secondly, it looked like goopy breadcrumbs. I thought maybe it would transform after a while in the oven. But it just looked like breadcrumbs in pastry. Which is not my idea of an amazing pudding.

I then spent a while googling “treacle tart” and looking at pictures of delicious-looking tarts and bemoaning my own stodgy-looking thing. Then I came across Nigel Slater’s attempt on the Guardian website, which looked pretty similar to my own actually. Eventually, mine started to brown off a bit and it’s similarity to Nigel’s began to make to wonder whether I had been too quick to criticise the aesthetics of the tart, rather than waiting for the most important test, the taste test! The proof of the pudding, as they say…

The finished product...

The finished product…

So on Sunday, with a slightly uneasy feeling, I announced to my boyfriend that we would be having treacle tart for pudding. What I wasn’t expecting was the response I got. He had no idea what treacle tart was, and didn’t even really remember what he ate at the grad ball (I blame the free bubbly!). He remembered eating a lot of it, but nothing more than that. Men = useless ๐Ÿ˜‰ *

That took away some of the pressure to compete with the wonderful dessert at grad ball, however. And thank God for that ๐Ÿ˜‰

My treacle tart was not disgusting. It was rather lemony. Too lemony for my taste really. But it didn’t taste syrupy or treacly at all. It was a bit chewy. The pastry was fine and there was not a soggy bottom to be seen – thanks, Mary for your handy hints!

If I had to some it up in one word, that word would be, “Blah”.

Everyone politely smothered their tart with ice cream and cleaned their plate… And then turned down a second helping ๐Ÿ˜‰

Well, I guess things can’t always go your way. I’m still waiting to prove to my boyfriend that I can actually cook reasonably well, but at least I didn’t give anyone food poisoning!

Unfortunately, we didn’t choose the right recipe. Then again, you never know with recipes until you try them.

I’m not going to put the recipe I did use up, because you don’t want to try it. The finished product wasn’t terrible, but I wouldn’t recommend it either, so I’ll spare you all ๐Ÿ™‚

Here’s the great Mary Berry’s recipe, which I plan on making next time (although I plan on reducing the lemon quantities, as I don’t like things to be too lemony, unlike Mary)!

Anyway, on a completely different note, I have been nominated for a couple more awards this week! Luckily neither of them was the “Amazing Treacle Tart Award”, as I may have had to turn that one down ๐Ÿ˜‰

Many, many thanks to The Jenny Mac Book Blog for nominating me for the Wonderful Team Member Readership Award ๐Ÿ˜€ Go on, go and have a look at her blog… you know you want to ๐Ÿ™‚


And thank you, merci and danke to Chef Randall from Savor the Food for nominating my little blog for the Sunshine Award!! Head over to his blog to find loads of recipes you can “savor” or “savour”, depending on which side of the Pond you come from ๐Ÿ˜‰ Seriously though, recommended reading!


Right now, so I’m off to do something exciting which I couldn’t possibly tell you all about (okay, okay, it’s Christmas and birthday present wrapping…)

I wish you all the best of luck with your last minute present buying and food preparation ๐Ÿ™‚

Merry Christmas!!

Katie x

*not really, sorry men for tarring you all with the same brush ๐Ÿ™‚


18 comments on “The Great Treacle Tart Recipe Dispute

  1. motherhoodisanart
    December 19, 2012

    Oh, that’s hilarious! Loved the story! I’ve had far too many cooking mishaps in the kitchen that I am always happy when I don’t give anyone food poisoning!! Melissa

    • mixitupandmakeitnice
      December 19, 2012

      It’s always the standard to aim for ๐Ÿ˜‰ And I don’t think anything I could cook would ever beat my Grandma’s rice pudding she made once without the rice… K x

      • motherhoodisanart
        December 19, 2012

        Oh…my…god!! Perfect!!!

      • mixitupandmakeitnice
        December 19, 2012

        It was pretty funny. She just ended up with a bowl of hot, nutmeggy milk ๐Ÿ™‚

  2. explodyfull
    December 19, 2012

    lol can’t believe your bf couldn’t really remember the cake from the party. Better luck with the cake next time!

    • mixitupandmakeitnice
      December 19, 2012

      I know! I couldn’t believe it! I was trying to be thoughtful, but it just didn’t work out ๐Ÿ˜‰

  3. petit4chocolatier
    December 20, 2012

    Love your post! I have had so many mishaps with recipes. It happens. We learn.
    Congratulations on your awards!!!!

    • mixitupandmakeitnice
      December 20, 2012

      So true ๐Ÿ™‚ You never know how something is going to turn out until you try it! And thank you! K x

  4. coffeeanddessert
    December 20, 2012

    Funny story, the next time you’ll get it right!! I had a similar story regarding “brigadeiros” a sweet from Brazil, my first attempt was a disaster to say the least and I promised myself that I would never do that again. I didn’t kept that promise but it was worth it because the second time was perfect ๐Ÿ™‚
    Merry Christmas!

    • mixitupandmakeitnice
      December 20, 2012

      I just googled “brigadeiros”, they look goooood!! Glad that the second time went well – hopefully my next attempt at a treacle tart will be just as good ๐Ÿ˜€ Feliz Natal to you too (I hope that’s right!) ๐Ÿ™‚

  5. sylvia
    December 20, 2012

    Ah…I hate it when so much work turns out so disappointing. Next time.

    • mixitupandmakeitnice
      December 20, 2012

      Yeah, you’re right – that’s the most annoying part! Yup, fingers crossed for next time… although I might leave treacle tart for a while now ๐Ÿ˜‰

  6. scroungelady
    December 22, 2012

    Agree that it is better to taste good than look good. As I used to tell my students, many of the recipes you find, especially on the Web, are C___! Consider the tart a learning experience. We do learn from our mistakes – I certainly have had lots of learning experiences!

    • mixitupandmakeitnice
      December 23, 2012

      Yeah, sometimes you need to make mistakes so you can work out how to make things better! Saying that I made a cheesecake yesterday which turned out very weird, and I have absolutely no idea what I did wrong… maybe I’ll just ditch that recipe (yes, I found it online…)! ๐Ÿ™‚

      • scroungelady
        December 23, 2012

        I stand on a mountain of mistakes!

  7. lalarukh1
    July 2, 2013

    Lol that was funny….I haven’t started cooking for real yet I guess I would make lots of mistakes like this ๐Ÿ˜› Loved you blog made my mouth water ๐Ÿ˜›
    Do check me at http://www.foodpeopleloveandstuff.wordpress.com

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Enter your email address to follow this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 240 other followers

%d bloggers like this: